Skip to content
Rechnungskit
Live demo

Handle a dispute or chargeback

Updated

The "Dispute" task reports that a customer disputed a payment or your payment provider pulled it back: a card chargeback, a buyer dispute (on Stripe also for Klarna payments) or a SEPA return debit (Rücklastschrift). The task reminder by email, which is in German, lists it as "Rücklastschrift".

Dispute received
Automatic first, then exactly one step for you
  1. TriggerStripe reports a disputeafter a chargeback the invoice shows as "Charged back", after an inquiry it does not
  2. RechnungskitFetches reason and deadline, submits proof of shipmentwhen the order shipped with a tracking number and the reason fits
  3. YouOnly if the card names a stepone button takes you straight to the dispute in Stripe
  4. OutcomeWon: the task closeslost: the receivable is open again and the task closes with the repayment
None of these cases creates a cancellation invoice.

Inquiry or chargeback

Not every dispute costs money right away. On Klarna almost every case starts as an inquiry, and for cards the bank can send an early inquiry. Stripe reports both with a status that starts with "warning_". At this stage no money has been taken back.

  • During an inquiry Rechnungskit books nothing. The invoice stays paid and the DATEV export has no booking for it. The card is called "Klarna inquiry" (for cards "Inquiry, no chargeback yet") and says: "No money has been taken back yet. Respond before the deadline, or it turns into a chargeback."
  • Klarna does not accept evidence during an inquiry. Sort it out with the customer or refund before the deadline. If the order shipped with a tracking number, Rechnungskit submits the proof of shipment automatically once the inquiry becomes a chargeback. An inquiry about a card payment gets answered right away, the same way as a dispute.
  • When the inquiry closes, the task closes and nothing is booked.
  • When the inquiry turns into a chargeback, Rechnungskit books the chargeback, the invoice shows as "Charged back", and the rest of this page applies.

Until 20 October 2026 Rechnungskit booked inquiries as chargebacks. It removes those bookings on its own, and the invoices count as paid again. If such a booking is already in a locked DATEV export, the export stays unchanged and the card tells you that your tax advisor corrects the booking there.

What Rechnungskit does automatically

  • It fetches the reason, the response deadline, the payment method and the status of the dispute from Stripe when the dispute arrives and every four hours after that. Older tasks get these details filled in on the first run.
  • If the order shipped with a tracking number and the customer says the goods never arrived, does not recognise the payment, suspects fraud, or the bank files a general objection, Rechnungskit submits the evidence to Stripe itself: tracking number, carrier, ship date, delivery address, the buyer's email and name, the items, and a short summary with the order and invoice number. If the invoice is archived, it goes along as a PDF. This happens once per dispute, through your own Stripe connection, and the card then says so ("Proof of shipment submitted automatically on 21 Oct").
  • If you win, the task closes. If you lose, it stays open and shows the way forward for the receivable.
  • An order with an open dispute that has not shipped yet carries the red note "Open dispute · do not ship" under Orders, also in the "Awaiting shipment" filter. Rechnungskit cannot stop the shipment in your shop.

Rechnungskit does not answer other reasons itself, such as faulty goods, a refund the customer did not get, a double charge or a cancelled subscription. Only you can judge what is true there.

The setting

Under Settings → Document rules → Disputes you find the switch "Submit proof of shipment automatically". It is on from the start. If you switch it off, Rechnungskit submits nothing, and the card still shows the reason, the deadline and the next step. Every change goes into the activity log.

A restricted Stripe key needs the "Disputes: Write" permission to submit, and "Files: Write" for the invoice PDF (see the table under Connect Stripe). Without it, Stripe refuses the first submission and Rechnungskit stops trying on its own. The evidence stays prepared, the card names the missing permission and takes you to the dispute with "Submit evidence in Stripe ↗". Once you have extended the key, tap "Try again" under Document rules → Disputes.

The case card

Under Invoices → To review, each dispute has its own card with:

  • the amount and the reason in plain words, for example "Customer says: not received" or "Suspected fraud"
  • the deadline, for example "respond by 28 Oct, 8 days left", in red under three days
  • the order, the invoice and the shipping status, for example "shipped on 06 Oct, no tracking number"
  • what Rechnungskit has already done
  • exactly one recommended action, with a button where you need one
Situation Recommendation on the card
Klarna inquiry, shipped with a tracking number Nothing to do: Klarna doesn't accept evidence during an inquiry. If it turns into a chargeback, Rechnungskit submits the proof of shipment automatically.
Klarna inquiry, otherwise "Open inquiry in Stripe ↗": sort it out with the customer or refund before the deadline.
Inquiry in a locked DATEV export (booked as a chargeback before 20 October 2026) Tell your tax advisor, who corrects the booking in the export. Then "Mark as done".
Shipped with a tracking number, the reason fits Nothing to do: Rechnungskit submits the proof of shipment and reports the outcome.
Evidence submitted Nothing to do. We'll report the outcome.
Shipped, but no tracking number "Upload proof of shipment in Stripe ↗", for example the shipping receipt or proof of delivery.
Not shipped yet Do not ship. Decide in Stripe: accept the dispute (the customer keeps the money, cancel the order) or ship and then contest it.
A reason only you can answer "Respond in Stripe ↗", for example with the product description, your return policy or a refund receipt.
No shipment (service, digital) "Upload proof of service in Stripe ↗", for example access details or a usage log.
Stripe key without "Disputes: Write" Extend the key and tap "Try again"; until then, "Submit evidence in Stripe ↗".
Deadline passed The bank decides without a response; we report the outcome.
Lost The receivable is open again. If the customer pays again, link the payment with "Assign repayment" and the task closes. If they don't, collect the amount yourself or book it as a bad debt with your tax advisor, then close the task with "Mark as done".
No original invoice Rechnungskit has neither an order nor an invoice for the payment, for example because it predates your document start. Check the case at the payment provider.
Another payment provider Respond directly at Mollie, PayPal or GoCardless. Mollie only reports the outcome, so the card says "no deadline reported" there.

Buttons marked ↗ open the dispute directly in the Stripe dashboard, in the test area for a test key. The same details appear in the row on the dashboard, in the task reminder and in the email your account gets once when the dispute arrives. That email goes to the contact email from the settings, or, if there is none, to the account owner.

Why Rechnungskit does not cancel the invoice

A chargeback reverses the payment, not the sale. The goods or service were delivered, the invoice stays valid and the customer still owes the amount. That is why Rechnungskit deliberately does not create a cancellation invoice (Storno) but marks the invoice as "Charged back".

A repayment counts toward the same invoice. No new document and no cancellation are created. Rechnungskit links it automatically only when the payment names the order or invoice number, for example in the payment reference. Customer or amount alone are not reliable proof. Without the number, Rechnungskit flags the payment as a possible repayment and you link it with one click.

How to resolve it

  1. Open Invoices → To review and read the recommendation on the card. If it says "Nothing to do", wait for the outcome.
  2. If the card names a step, the button opens the dispute in Stripe. Respond there before the deadline.
  3. If the order has not shipped yet, do not ship it before you have decided in Stripe. If you accept the dispute, cancel the order in your shop.
  4. If the case is lost, ask the customer for the amount. Dunning and debiting again are not part of the product.
  5. If the receivable turns out to be permanently uncollectible, clarify with your tax advisor whether a bad-debt correction is needed. Rechnungskit does not create a cancellation for this.
  6. When the repayment comes in, tap "Assign repayment" on the card of the lost case. Rechnungskit lists unassigned payments that may fit: first the ones flagged as a possible repayment, then those from the same customer, then those with a matching amount. Pick one and it counts toward the charged-back invoice. The other way round, the "Possible repayment" card shows the charged-back invoices the payment may belong to.
  7. If the customer does not pay and the case is settled for you, mark the task as done with "Mark as done". Rechnungskit records in the activity log who closed it and when. The invoice stays marked as charged back. Rechnungskit has no write-off of its own for a bad debt; your tax advisor books that.

In the DATEV export Rechnungskit books the chargeback against the debtor, on the clearing account (Geldtransit) of the payment provider concerned. The receivable is therefore open again in the books too (see DATEV export and your tax advisor). A linked repayment books like any payment against the same debtor, which then balances again.

When the task closes on its own

If you win the dispute, you keep the money and Rechnungskit closes the task automatically. The same happens when an inquiry ends without a chargeback. Rechnungskit closes a lost case once the linked repayments cover the charged-back amount to the cent, whether they were linked automatically via the order number or by you. A partial payment keeps the task open, and its text then names what is still owed. The "Possible repayment" task closes when you link the payment. If the customer never pays, close the task yourself with "Mark as done".

The task counts towards the menu badge under Invoices, because that is where you close it in the "To review" tab.

Related settings

  • Settings → Document rules → Disputes: submit proof of shipment automatically (on or off)
  • Settings: contact email, which receives the notification about open disputes
  • Settings → DATEV settings: account mapping for payments and chargebacks

Where to find it in the app

Rechnungskit is not a tax advisory or law firm. This article explains general principles and does not replace advice from a tax advisor (Steuerberater, § 5 StBerG) or a lawyer (§ 3 RDG). Rechnungskit is built for businesses based in Germany and prepares documents, tax rates and bookings automatically. How your specific case is treated remains your decision, ideally together with your tax advisor or a lawyer.

de en